I just finished making the following recipe, courtesy of Deborah Flateman…former CEO of the Vermont Foodbank and the woman who hired me for my first real job. i remember the first time Deb cooked for me…it was a staff meeting. i can still taste that risotto pie. she is an amazing cook and this recipe will not disappoint. ENJOY every bite–and follow to the letter!
By Deborah Flateman
What can you say about peaches? When they’re good, they’re really, really good. And when they’re not, well, the disappointment one can feel is beyond description. You know, when they’re dry, mealy, tough- skinned. Not juicy and tender and sweet perhaps like the ones I remember picking from my grandfather’s tree that, despite his gross lack of attention, still managed to produce small, sugar-sweet orbs of summer delight. Juice running down the chin with every bite. Heaven.
My former husband is a guy who, within ten minutes of talking with him, was able to take you into a zillion directional paths. One day at work where he came in contact with lots of folks from all over the country, he struck up a conversation with a real, honest-to-goodness Georgia peach (a really nice lady from Macon) who promised to send her recipe for peach custard pie. And true to her ‘peachiness’ form, she sent this recipe that has become my absolute favorite in the celebration of our fuzzy, pulpy passion. I also include my mom’s tried and true recipe for flaky pie crust. Give this one a try! The process is easier than you think, and the outcome is absolutely outstanding.
Mom’s Pie Crust
2/3 C (heaping) Crisco
2 C Flour
6 T Cold Water
Cut the flour and salt into the Crisco until it resembles coarse meal. Add the water and mix in. Don’t work the dough too hard or it will be tough. This is enough dough for a double crust 10-inch pie.
Peach Custard Pie (preheat oven to 375 degrees)
- Line a 10-inch pie plate with Mom’s pie crust (use store bought if you must!).
- In a large bowl, beat 3 eggs, 1 C sugar, 3 T flour, 1 t vanilla, and ½ C of melted, unsalted butter (in that order). Set aside.
- Peel and slice peaches (about 6 large) into the lined pie plate (peaches should fill the pie plate by about two thirds).
- Pour custard mixture over the peaches.
- Apply a lattice top over the batter and crimp edges (only a lattice top will work here).
- Brush with egg wash and sprinkle sparsely with sugar.
Bake for one hour. Serves 6-8 happy people. This recipe also works with frozen peaches if you have a hankering when fresh ones aren’t around.